Skip to content

This site uses cookies to store information on your computer. Some are essential to make our site work; others help us improve the user experience. By using the site, you consent to the placement of these cookies. Read our privacy policy to learn more.

Close
aicpa-logo-black
  • AICPA Resources:
  • AICPA-CIMA.com
  • Tax Section
  • Store
The Tax Adviser
  • INDIVIDUALS
    • All articles
    • Credits
    • Deductions
    • Income
    • Specialized Issues

    Latest Stories

    • Treasury posts preliminary list of jobs eligible for no tax on tips
    • Tax strategies for highly appreciated undeveloped land
    • Draft 2026 Form W-2 includes boxes and codes for tips and overtime
    • No proceeds from sale of husband’s home to pay tax debts go to wife
  • PASSTHROUGHS
    • All articles
    • S Corporations
    • Partnerships & LLCs
    • Contributions, Distributions & Basis
    • Reporting & Filing Requirements

    Latest Stories

    • Signing partnerships’ returns and other tax documents
    • Prop. regs. would modify reporting obligations for Form 8308, Part IV
    • IRS includes several AICPA recommendations in corporate AMT interim guidance
    • Potential recapture pitfall for profits-interest partners
  • CORPORATIONS
    • All articles
    • Deductions
    • Formation & Reorganizations
    • Income
    • Reporting & Filing Requirements

    Latest Stories

    • AI is transforming transfer pricing
    • Guidance on research or experimental expenditures under H.R. 1 issued
    • AICPA presses IRS for guidance on domestic research costs in OBBBA
    • IRS includes several AICPA recommendations in corporate AMT interim guidance
  • ESTATES
    • All articles
    • Estate Tax
    • Gift Tax
    • Tax Computation
    • Types of Trusts

    Latest Stories

    • Estate tax considerations for non-US persons owning US real estate
    • The final countdown: Benefiting from the higher BEA before it potentially expires
    • Proposed regulations update QDOT regulations
  • PROCEDURE
    • All articles
    • Collections & Liens
    • Representations & Examinations
    • Tax Planning & Minimization

    Latest Stories

    • Treasury posts preliminary list of jobs eligible for no tax on tips
    • Tax Court addresses dueling motions to dismiss
    • Scope of review in passport cases is de novo
    • Practical considerations for taxpayers and advisers following Loper Bright and Corner Post
  • Home
  • News
  • Magazine
  • Topics
Advertisement
  1. newsletter
  2. TAX INSIDER
TAX INSIDER

Should S Corporations Get Ordinary Loss Treatment for Losses on Subsidiary Stock?

By Sally P. Schreiber, J.D.
October 1, 2015

Please note: This item is from our archives and was published in 2015. It is provided for historical reference. The content may be out of date and links may no longer function.

Related

August 1, 2015

UBTI Reporting Requirements for Partnerships and S Corporations

February 1, 2015

IRS Clarifies That a Former QSub Cannot Prorate Post-Termination Items of Income or Loss

January 1, 2015

The Transfer of Loss Property Between an S Corporation and Its Shareholders

TOPICS

  • S Corporation Income Taxation
    • Allocations of Profits & Losses

S corporations generally are taxed differently from C corporations because their income and losses are passed through to their shareholders, rather than taxed at the corporate level. But there are a number of situations where both types of corporations are treated similarly. For example, an S corporation, like a C corporation, can make a Sec. 338(d) election when it makes a qualified stock purchase and can liquidate a subsidiary tax-free under Sec. 332 (Letter Ruling 9245004).

The question of whether an S corporation should be treated the same as a C corporation when its subsidiary corporation is insolvent has not been definitively answered, however. Does Sec. 165(g)(1), which treats any security that is a capital asset and becomes worthless during the tax year as a capital loss, apply? Or does Sec. 165(g)(3), which treats losses on securities in affiliated corporations as ordinary losses, apply? An affiliated corporation for purposes of Sec. 165(g)(3) is defined under Sec. 1504(a)(2) as a corporation that owns at least 80% of both the vote and value of the stock in another corporation. (There is also a gross receipts test that is not relevant here.)   

When do C corporation rules apply to S corporations?

Sec. 1371(a) provides that, except as otherwise provided in the Code or to the extent it is inconsistent with Subchapter S, Subchapter C applies to an S corporation and its shareholders. Sec. 1363(b), on the other hand, provides that, except for enumerated exceptions, the “taxable income of an S corporation shall be computed in the same manner as in the case of an individual . . .” So, is Sec. 1363(b) or Sec. 1371(a) more relevant when determining whether an S corporation can take an ordinary loss deduction for losses on a subsidiary’s stock?

In Rev. Rul. 93-36, the IRS dealt with the treatment under Sec. 166 of a nonbusiness bad debt incurred by an S corporation. The IRS ruled that under Sec. 1363(b) an S corporation is treated as a “taxpayer other than a corporation” and thus is subject to the less favorable tax treatment that applies to individual taxpayers. However, arguably this ruling should not be determinative of the proper treatment of an S corporation for purposes of Sec. 165(g)(3) because it does not address business bad debts and does not involve securities.

Sec. 165(g)(3) applies to losses when a corporation owns stock in a subsidiary corporation that is wholly owned or almost wholly owned (80/80 rule under Sec. 1504(a)(2)). When an S corporation owns a subsidiary in these circumstances, is there any reason to treat the corporation as an individual taxpayer? Under the original S corporation rules, this was not an issue because S corporations were prohibited from owning sufficient stock in a corporation to satisfy the 80/80 rule, so the provisions of Sec. 165(g)(3) were not applicable.

However, changes enacted in the Small Business Job Protection Act of 1996, P.L. 104-188, revised the S corporation rules in ways intended, at least in part, to treat C and S corporations more similarly. This included allowing S corporations to own subsidiaries that met the 80/80 rule of Sec. 1504(a)(2). In this changed environment, it would seem consistent to allow S corporations to take advantage of Sec. 165(g)(3)—but the IRS has never provided definitive guidance on this issue, and Sec. 1363(b) and Rev. Rul. 93-36 are still good law and still regard S corporations as individuals.    

The alternative to Sec. 165(g)(3) for a parent corporation that wants to liquidate a subsidiary is to use Sec. 332, which permits tax-free liquidations of subsidiaries, even when owned by S corporations. But Sec. 332 cannot be used with insolvent subsidiaries because Regs. Sec. 1.332-2(b) requires the parent corporation to obtain some payment for the stock it is liquidating and the parent receives no payment for the subsidiary’s stock in a liquidation if, at the time of the liquidation, the fair market value of the subsidiary’s assets is less than the subsidiary’s liabilities. Thus, the alternative to a Sec. 332 liquidation, taking an ordinary loss under Sec. 165(g)(3), it is reasonable to conclude, should be equally available to both S and C corporations. 

AICPA position

On Sept. 18, 2015, Troy Lewis, chair of the AICPA Tax Executive Committee, submitted a comment letter addressing this issue. The AICPA recommends the position that these losses should be ordinary, not capital, losses, and the letter encourages the IRS and Treasury to provide guidance that S corporations are entitled to the benefits of Sec. 165(g)(3) to the same extent as C corporations.

—Sally P. Schreiber (sschreiber@aicpa.org) is a Tax Insider senior editor.

Advertisement

Latest News

September 4, 2025

Treasury posts preliminary list of jobs eligible for no tax on tips

August 31, 2025

AI is transforming transfer pricing

August 30, 2025

2025 tax software survey

August 30, 2025

Tax Court addresses dueling motions to dismiss

August 30, 2025

Scope of review in passport cases is de novo

Advertisement

Most Read

Partnership distributions: Rules and exceptions
Current developments in S corporations
Reporting aspects of Sec. 743(b) adjustments
The Sec. 645 election to treat a trust as part of the estate
Paid student-athletes: Tax implications for universities and donors
Partnership Capital Account Revaluations: An In-Depth Look at Sec. 704(c) Allocations
Advertisement

employee benefits & pensions

Abstract image of pie chart, with pieces being pulled from several directions. IMAGE BY VECTORMINE/ADOBE STOCK

Profits interests: The most tax-efficient equity grant to employees

By granting them a profits interest, entities taxed as partnerships can reward employees with equity. Mistakes, however, could cause challenges from taxing authorities.

Tax Clinic

Proposed regulations issued on retirement catch-up contributions

IC-DISC commission payment provisions

The role of REITs for foreign investors in US real estate

Signing partnerships’ returns and other tax documents

Practical considerations for taxpayers and advisers following Loper Bright and Corner Post

Magazine

August 2025

August 2025

August 2025
July 2025

July 2025

July 2025
June 2025

June 2025

June 2025
May 2025

May 2025

May 2025
April 2025

April 2025

April 2025
March 2025

March 2025

March 2025
February 2025

February 2025

February 2025
January 2025

January 2025

January 2025
December 2024

December 2024

December 2024
November 2024

November 2024

November 2024
October 2024

October 2024

October 2024
SEPTEMBER 2024

SEPTEMBER 2024

SEPTEMBER 2024
view all

View All

http://view-all

JOIN

AICPA Tax Section

Your go-to source for tax developments and professional insights. Tap into expert guidance, tools, news, and career development.

Connect

  • x-logo The Tax Adviser on X
  • Linkedin AICPA Tax Practitioners on Linkedin

HOME

  • News
  • Monthly issues
  • Tax Insider articles
  • Topics
  • RSS feed rss feed
  • Sitemap

ABOUT

  • About The Tax Adviser
  • Contact us
  • Submit an article
  • Advertise
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms & conditions

JOIN/SUBSCRIBE

  • AICPA Tax Section
  • CPE Express

AICPA & CIMA Sites

  • AICPA-CIMA.com
  • Journal of Accountancy
  • Financial Management (FM)
  • Global Engagement Center
  • Global Career Hub
aicpa-logo-black

© 2025 Association of International Certified Professional Accountants. All rights reserved.